A Place for Truth Studies

Major Doctrinal Controversies in the Christian Church

I: Major Ancient Church Doctrinal Controversies

Controversy Major Heretical Leaders Major Orthodox Leaders Relevant Councils Accepted Conclusions
Trinitarian Controversy Arius / Eusebius of Nicomedia Athanasius / Hosius / Basil the Great / Gregory of Nyssa / Augustine of Hippo Nicea (325) Constantinople (381) Christ is "of same substance with the Father." Father, Son, and Spirit are "coeternal, consubstantial, and coequal."
Christological Controversy Apollinarius Nestoriaus Eutyches Cyril of Alexandria Theodoret / Leo I Constantinople (381) Ephesus (431) Chalcedon (451) Christ is "one person in two natures, unmixed, unchanged, undivided, inseperable." Mary is "the Mother of God."
Donatist Controversy Donatus Caecilian Augustine of Hippo Arles (314) "Outside the church there is no salvation."
Pelagian Controversy Pelagius Coelestius / John Cassian / Caesarius of Arles Augustine of Hippo / Jerome Ephesus (431) Orange (529) Semi-Augustinianism; sacramental grace enables people to overcome their innate sinfulness.

II: Trinitarian Heresies